“Pass The Bowl” is VH1’s ongoing interview series, wherein celebrities contribute questions to our bowl and fellow celebs later draw a question.

Debbie Gibson: What was your first concert?

Arnar Rósenkranz Hilmarsson, Of Monsters And Men: Probably something Icelandic.

Brynjar Leifsson, Of Monsters And Men: I went to the Strokes in 2001 when I was 11.

Arnar: I probably went to see Foo Fighters in Iceland in two thousand and something. Well, that’s the first one I remember. 

Of Monsters And Men’s Question For The Bowl: What’s your favorite worst nightmare?

Tune into Big Morning Buzz Live every weekday at 10AM EST on VH1.

[Photos: Jen Marigliano/VH1]